Google Play Reinstates Bigo, Tango, and Similar Apps Amid Content Policy Updates

Google Play Reinstates Bigo, Tango, and Similar Apps Amid Content Policy Updates

by | Dec 25, 2024 | Reviews

In a recent development, Google Play has removed several popular social and live streaming apps from its Play Store, including Bigo and Tango. This move has raised questions regarding the platform’s stance on user-generated content (UGC) and its enforcement of CSAE (Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation) policies. Apps like Bigo, Tango, and others typically allow live interactions between users, which can sometimes lead to the spread of inappropriate content, making them more vulnerable to CASE policy breaches.
In order to show compliance with the new content and safety standards, developers of those apps are required to fill out the Children’s Safety Standard Declaration and submit other CSAE-related documentation to Google Play.
Google Play reinstates Bigo, Tango, and similar apps amid policy updates

Filling Out the Children's Safety Standard Declaration

Here is a breakdown of the steps and requirements:

1. Provide a URL for "Safety Standards" Compliance

  • Add a link to the CSAE compliance statement in your app’s Privacy Policy or Terms of Service.
  • Ensure that the link is functional at all times and accessible to users in the app.
  • Provide this link to Google Play via the Play Console when submitting or updating your app.

2. Incorporate a Child Content Reporting Mechanism

Developers must add an in-app feedback mechanism that allows users to report child safety concerns directly within the app. This mechanism is required to allow users (including parents or guardians) to report inappropriate content or behavior involving minors, including potential CSAE violations. Then, in your Google Play Console or app management center, you need to provide proof that the reporting feature has been integrated properly.

What Else Can Developers Do in Face of Google Play's Stricter Scrutiny?

After the initial removals on December 16, some top social and live streaming apps like Bigo, Tango, and LiveMe were reinstated, indicating that the developers either made necessary changes to meet the stringent standards or Google Play revised its approach. For instance, Tango returned soon after 7 days without any updates, as the app version remains the same as the day it was removed (#8.80.1732719153). Whereas, it took 2 weeks for Bigo’s developers to make adjustments to the app and submit an updated version (from #6.22.4 to #6.23.2) before being reinstated on December 20.
Here are some suggestions and practices for developers to cope with Google’s tighter app review policies, especially related to CSAE content and ensuring safe, continuous app operations:

1. Develop Internal Safety Guidelines

Establish comprehensive internal guidelines that specifically address CSAE issues. These guidelines will help internal teams identify, prevent, and address CSAE-related content, particularly within apps involving UGC or live streaming.

2. Streamline and Enable Easy Reporting Channels

Implement clear reporting mechanisms within the app that comply with local laws. Users should be able to report suspected CSAE content or other harmful behaviors easily without leaving the app.

3. Use Technology to Detect CSAE Content

Leverage automated technologies (e.g. hash matching, image classifier, keyword extraction tools) to scan content for CSAE, including images, videos, and text. This technology can help detect inappropriate or harmful content proactively.

4. Ongoing Monitoring and Updates

Regularly update the app’s policies and safety features to align with new legal requirements or changes in Google Play’s content guidelines. Ensure continuous monitoring of the app’s compliance.

5. Adopt Progressive Web Apps

While Google Play’s stricter policies are meant to protect users and create a safe online environment, the enforcement has put social and live streaming app developers under constant compliance pressure. Listing apps on the platform has become more difficult than ever as apps are being thoroughly scrutinized in the lengthy approval process. In this context, the Progressive Web App (PWA) solution offered by ROIBest emerges as an attractive alternative.
PWAs allow developers to bypass the complexities of traditional app stores, providing a seamless user experience directly through web browsers. With PWAs, there’s no need to worry about app store approvals, distribution fees, or platform restrictions. Developers can reach users on any device with a modern web browser, ensuring faster updates, improved accessibility, and greater flexibility. This approach not only eliminates the friction associated with app store listings but also positions developers to take full control of their app’s lifecycle while delivering a high-quality experience to users across multiple platforms.

About Us

ROIBest is a software service company headquartered in Singapore, pioneering in Android progressive web app (PWA) solutions. We provide Android developers with an innovative app distribution & advertising solution that does not depend on app stores, saves in-app purchase commissions, and eliminates harmful file warnings. Our feature-rich product supports AudienceCloud, traffic deduplication, and intelligent push notifications, enabling business success in global markets.

roibest, pioneer in nin-removable Android apps, no.1 pwa service provider

Frequently Asked Questions

PWA or Progressive Web Application is an app written in a web language (JavaScript + frameworks) that works as a native mobile or desktop application.

It holds many mobile app features, such as:

  • Push notifications
  • Offline/background support
  • Camera, geolocation, gesture navigation

Unlike traditional apps, you don’t have to download it — just open it in your browser.

PWA combines the accessibility of a mobile website with the experience of a native app. It doesn’t require installation and provides features like:

  • Push notifications
  • Camera & barcode scanning
  • Gesture navigation and geolocation

All modern desktop and mobile browsers support PWAs and the technologies behind them, such as service workers and web manifests.

Yes — as long as the device uses a modern browser and the PWA meets Google’s Lighthouse and checklist requirements.

Very old devices with outdated OS or browsers may not fully support PWAs.

Global App Downloads Decline by 2.3% in 2024

Global App Downloads Decline by 2.3% in 2024

by | Dec 24, 2024 | Reviews

Recovery in Global App Spending vs. Google Play Decline

On December 19, Appfigures, the app intelligence company, released its latest stats, revealing a steady rise in consumer in-app spending in 2024—marking the first increase since the economic slowdown of 2022.
A closer look at the numbers shows that the total spend amounting to $127 billion across platformswith an annual growth of 15.7%. This growth was largely driven by App Store which contributed $91.6 billion with 24% increase compared to last year, whereas Google Play saw a drop in its in-app purchases by 1.5% to $35.7 billion.
Global Consumer Spending in Mobile Apps

Image credit: Appfigures

Notable Decline in Global App Downloads

While the consumer in-app spending has shown an upward trend this year, the globle app downloads experienced a notable decline. In 2024, total mobile app downloads worldwide was down by 2.3% to 110 billion, with a more significant drop by 2.6% observed on Google Play falling to 81.4 billion.

Global Downloads of Mobile Apps

Image credit: Appfigures

Reasons Behind Decline and Challenges for Developers

This downturn is partially attributed to the enforcement of stricter review policies across app stores in 2024. For the past year, Google Play has carried out a rigorous purge on its listings, leading to the removal and rejection of numerous apps that failed to meet the updated standards. This move aiming to clear spams and improve app quality has resulted in a 60% decrease in newly published apps on the Play Store.
In addition to the policy changes on Google Play, the overall decrease in app downloads can be linked to market saturation and shifting user behaviors. As the app ecosystem matures, users are becoming more selective, often favoring established applications over new entrants. This trend poses challenges for developers striving to achieve visibility and user acquisition in an increasingly competitive environment.
To navigate this evolving landscape, developers are encouraged to prioritize app quality, intuitive user interface, and most importantly, innovative features that meet user needs. Emerging solutions like Progressive Web Apps (PWAs) that streamline development process and enhance user experience also provide new perspectives for developers.

About Us

ROIBest is a software service company headquartered in Singapore, pioneering in Android progressive web app (PWA) solutions. We provide Android developers with an innovative app distribution & advertising solution that does not depend on app stores, saves in-app purchase commissions, and eliminates harmful file warnings. Our feature-rich product supports AudienceCloud, traffic deduplication, and intelligent push notifications, enabling business success in global markets.

roibest, non-removable Android apps, no.1 PWA service provider
World’s Top 5 Progressive Web App Tools

World’s Top 5 Progressive Web App Tools

by | Dec 23, 2024 | Reviews

Progressive Web Apps (PWAs) are transforming the way we build web experiences, offering the best of both web and mobile apps. To create high-performance PWAs, developers need the right tools for development, testing, and deployment. In this article, we highlight the top 5 PWA tools that help streamline the process, ensuring faster, more reliable apps. 

1. ROIBest

ROIBest is a Singapore company that specializes in Progressive Web App (PWA) packaging and advertising solutions, offering a range of standout features that set it apart from other providers in this industry.
With ROIBest, developers can convert their website into a PWA with one click by just providing an URL. The plaltform includes robust features like domain resolution and protection, ad attribution tracking, and promo link creation.
As a cutting-edge PWA tool, ROIBest delivers the most comprehensive app packaging and distribution capabilities, all within an intuitive and user-friendly interface.

2. PWABuilder

PWABuilder is a PWA tool created by Microsoft that helps developers easily convert their websites into PWAs. PWABuilder streamlines only the PWA creation process by generating service workers, app manifests, and packaging apps for platforms like iOS, Android, and Microsoft Store.

3. Workbox

Workbox is a set of powerful libraries and tools developed by Google to simplify the process of adding offline support and advanced caching to PWAs. However, Workbox primarily focuses on offline capabilities, without providing tools for managing online interactions or live data updates.

4. Lighthouse

Lighthouse is another open-source tool from Google designed to audit and improve the quality of web apps, including PWAs. It provides actionable insights to enhance user experiences, but does not assist with the actual implementation or packaging of PWAs, leaving developers to rely on other tools or services for those critical steps.

5. PWAify

PWAify is a JavaScript library that allows developers to convert their traditional websites into PWAs with minimal effort. It simplifies the process by generating basic service workers and app manifests, making it suitable for small-scale projects or developers just starting with PWAs while looking to improve user experience with capabilities like offline mode and push notifications.

About Us

ROIBest is a software service company headquartered in Singapore, pioneering in Android progressive web app (PWA) solutions. We provide Android developers with an innovative app distribution & advertising solution that does not depend on app stores, saves in-app purchase commissions, and eliminates harmful file warnings. Our feature-rich product supports AudienceCloud, traffic deduplication, and intelligent push notifications, enabling business success in global markets.

roibest, pioneer in non-removable Android apps, no.1 PWA service provider
App Store Developer Q&A (3)

App Store Developer Q&A (3)

by | Dec 23, 2024 | Reviews

Preface

After tackling common questions for Google developers, we not shift our focus to the App Store as many Apple developers are facing similar challenges. This section aims to clarify key issues and provide solutions for those who are maintaining accounts and releasing apps on iOS.

Q1: Our game with voice chat features has been rejected three times under App Store Guideline 4.3 (Design: Spam), with appeals swiftly dismissed. How should we proceed?

A: Guideline 4.3 targets apps that duplicate existing functionality without significant differentiation, often labeling them as spam. To address this, consider requesting a direct conversation with the App Review team to identify whether the issue lies in your code or user interface. Particular attention should be paid to the client-side code to ensure it offers unique value and adheres to Apple’s standards.

Q2: What strategies have developers employed to overcome rejections under Guideline 4.3?

A: Developers have found that merely obfuscating code may not resolve 4.3 rejections. If development has consistently occurred on the same devices, especially those previously flagged, this could contribute to repeated rejections. Some developers suggest that the primary cause of 4.3(a) rejections is code similarity, recommending techniques like code obfuscation and reinforcement. Others advise launching a minimal viable product with core functionalities removed, then gradually adding features through updates after initial approval.

Q3: After a 4.3(a) rejection, will a complete code overhaul help pass automated reviews?

A: One approach involves creating a new developer account and following standard procedures to establish credibility. Developers have found success by initially submitting a simple tool app, iterating over 1-2 months. If no issues arise during this period, the account is likely in good standing, which can facilitate future submissions.

Q4: Does modifying our product's UI and structure suffice, or should we consider starting over with a new account?

A: Guideline 4.3 rejections don’t necessarily require abandoning your current account, as creating a new one can be resource-intensive. It’s advisable to thoroughly assess your app’s design and functionality to ensure it offers unique value. Engaging with the App Review team for specific feedback can also provide clarity on necessary improvements.

Q5: How can developers address verification requirements like utility bills or credit card statements for account validation?

A: Purchasing an iPhone from local stores and using region-specific IP addresses, along with virtual VISA cards from services like Airwallex, can help meet Apple’s verification criteria.

Q6: Can the same game, with identical code but different regional publishers, be listed on the App Store under separate developer accounts (e.g., Developer A for Japan, Developer B for Europe and the U.S.)?

A: Submitting identical apps under different developer accounts can lead to association issues and potential rejections. While creating derivative versions is possible, submitting identical apps is likely to be flagged under Guideline 4.3.

Q7: If an appeal results in an immediate automated rejection, is the iOS developer account compromised?

A: An immediate, template-based rejection following an appeal may indicate account association issues, which can compromise the account’s standing. In such cases, it’s crucial to review your app’s compliance with Apple’s guidelines and consider reaching out to Apple Support for further clarification.

Q8: When facing rejection due to "static content lacking value for a subscription," what does this imply, and how can we adjust to meet subscription criteria?

A: Apple may determine that your app’s content is better suited for a one-time in-app purchase rather than a subscription model. To qualify for subscriptions, consider offering dynamic, regularly updated content or services that provide ongoing value to users, aligning with Apple’s subscription guidelines.

About Us

ROIBest is a software service company headquartered in Singapore, pioneering in Android progressive web app (PWA) solutions. We provide Android developers with an innovative app distribution & advertising solution that does not depend on app stores, saves in-app purchase commissions, and eliminates harmful file warnings. Our feature-rich product supports AudienceCloud, traffic deduplication, and intelligent push notifications, enabling business success in global markets.

ROIBest pioneer in non-removable Android apps, no.1 PWA service provider
Google Play Store Developer Q&A (2)

Google Play Store Developer Q&A (2)

by | Dec 23, 2024 | Reviews

Preface

In December, Google Play intensified its enforcement of app review policies, leading to a significant increase in the removal of apps from its Play Store. This move aims to maintain the quality and integrity of the platform but has also posed substantial challenges for developers worldwide. From sudden account suspensions to the rejection of apps for vague or unexpected reasons, navigating these policies has become a critical aspect of app development and distribution.
In this Q&A section, we address some of the most pressing concerns faced by developers.

Q1: Is it safe to leave a newly created Google Play developer account unused, and is verification only required when uploading an app?

A: According to Google’s policies, developer accounts must undergo verification to ensure authenticity. The verification process is typically prompted during app submission, and leaving an account inactive without verification may lead to its closure due to inactivity.

Q2: Will developer accounts registered with shared office addresses be blacklisted by Google?

A: There have been reports suggesting that certain addresses used by multiple developers may be flagged by Google due to misuse. However, shared office addresses are common in the business world, and many companies using such addresses have not faced account suspensions.

Q3: Can submitting a simple tool app to test a Google Play developer account lead to suspension?

A: Yes, submitting apps with minimal functionality, such as simple tools, can result in rejection or suspension. Google’s Spam and Minimum Functionality policy targets apps that offer limited user value, considering them as spam. Recent policy updates aim to remove low-quality apps, including those with limited functionality or content, to enhance user experience.

Q4: Is it advisable to use an older developer account with existing apps for new submissions, and what are the risks of transferring apps to a new account later?

A: Utilizing an established developer account with a history of compliant apps can be beneficial, as it may have a positive trust factor with Google. However, transferring apps between accounts carries risks, including potential policy violations and loss of user data.

Q5: Has there been a slowdown in Google's app review process recently?

A: The duration of Google’s app review process can vary based on factors such as app type, complexity, and current review volumes. While some developers report longer review times, others experience swift approvals. For example, a developer mentioned that their live streaming app, which is an existing product, typically completes the review process in about half a day.

Q6: Does releasing an app in open testing affect user perception and subsequent downloads compared to a formal release?

A: Launching an app in open testing can impact user perception, as the app’s store listing will indicate its testing status. This transparency may deter some users, potentially affecting download rates and monetization.

About Us

ROIBest is a software service company headquartered in Singapore, pioneering in Android progressive web app (PWA) solutions. We provide Android developers with an innovative app distribution & advertising solution that does not depend on app stores, saves in-app purchase commissions, and eliminates harmful file warnings. Our feature-rich product supports AudienceCloud, traffic deduplication, and intelligent push notifications, enabling business success in global markets.

ROIBest pioneer in non-removable Android apps, no.1 PWA service provider
Verified by MonsterInsights